HCOL to LCOL: Our Geographic Cheat Code for FIRE

Our FIRE journey has taken us all over the United States. Along the way, we landed in Chattanooga, Tennessee. We only lived there for two years, but it might have been our favorite place yet. We had a small community of friends and family nearby who we saw regularly, and that's probably what made it feel so perfect.

Even so, we decided to leave for a new job that would dramatically shorten our time to financial independence (FI). It was an incredibly tough decision, and honestly, we still aren't sure it was the right one for us.

Be that as it may, we now live in Jersey City, which counts as a high cost of living (HCOL) area, maybe even very high (VHCOL). Housing alone costs us far more than it would in a medium cost of living (MCOL) city. Our core living costs, like rent, groceries and insurance, jumped from about $55,000 to $80,000 a year. But the move is still worth it financially, because we're able to save more now than we ever could before.

The FIRE math gets complicated

Normally, calculating your FIRE number is simple: take your annual cost of living and multiply it by 25. But we know we'll never spend our FIRE years in a HCOL area like this one. When we get there, we plan to move somewhere with a low or medium cost of living (LCOL or MCOL).

By our calculations, that move should easily cut about $20,000 a year from our spending. That's a huge deal for our FIRE number:

  • At $80,000 a year, we'd need about $2 million.

  • At $60,000 a year, we'd need about $1.5 million.

One move, and our target drops by half a million dollars.

The mental block

It sounds great on paper, but it's been surprisingly hard to accept that we'll really just cut our spending by 25%. The closer we get to FIRE, the bigger this mental block feels.

The stakes are high. Moving to a LCOL area could shave 4 to 7 years off our timeline. That's the difference between retiring in our 30s and retiring in our 40s. The upside is so big that it's hard to believe it's a real possibility.

The cheat code: go where the money is

I think this is a real cheat code for reaching FIRE. A lot of standard FIRE advice works within the life you already have: keep the same job, spend less and save more, or house hack where you live and slowly buy rentals.

For us, none of that worked. Instead, we saw the pay bumps people got just by being at the right company in the right city. I'm not talking about an extra $15,000. I'm talking about raises of $100,000 or more. That's a massive difference. No matter how frugal you are, there's only so much you can save on a $65,000 salary, even in a LCOL area.

If you can move somewhere that pays a premium for what you do, it can supercharge your path to FI, even after the higher cost of living.

Why this worked for us

This path has paid off for us, and it's still paying off, for two big reasons.

  1. We're young. We aren't caring for sick parents, and we don't have kids in a school they love surrounded by neighborhood friends. Any of that would have made the move far more emotionally difficult. Instead, we paid one extra month of rent, packed what we needed into our car, let the movers handle the rest and left. That's it. Leaving was easy.

  2. We never bought a house. Early in our financial journey, we heard the usual advice: buy a house as soon as possible and stop throwing money away on rent. So we looked at a lot of houses. But every time we found one we liked and ran the numbers, it never made sense. Renting was always a few hundred dollars a month cheaper, and that's before the hidden costs of owning a home. Not buying turned out to be one of the best decisions we've made. A house would have kept us from taking the kind of risks in our 20s that could set us up for life.

    A PSA for Gen Z (and Gen Alpha)

    If you're young, this one's for you: don't tie yourself down too early. Keep your options open long enough to see where they lead.

    Your 20s are when big moves are cheapest. There's no mortgage to sell, no kids to pull out of school, and no one counting on you to stay put. If you're in a career with real earning potential, one well-timed move to the right company in the right city could cut years off your path to FIRE.

Next
Next

How to Make your Numbers Work for you